Request a Meeting

Thun Financial is now Creative Planning International.

Why Americans Should Avoid Owning Shares in a Non-U.S. Mutual Fund

Creative Planning
Last Updated
March 15, 2022

Americans Should Avoid Non-U.S. Mutual Funds

Perhaps the most common and most significant investment mistake made by Americans abroad is to buy a foreign mutual fund (including ETFs or other types of non-U.S.-based funds). The U.S. tax code categorizes non-U.S. registered mutual funds as Passive Foreign Investment Companies (PFICs). PFICs are taxed very punitively by the U.S. Furthermore, each PFIC must be reported annually on U.S. tax form 8621, which requires complex accounting and is very time consuming to complete.

For many years following the passage of the original 1986 PFIC legislation, U.S. expats could comfortably ignore the PFIC rules. The lack of cross-border financial transparency made it impossible for the IRS to collect the information needed to enforce the PFIC tax provisions. However, this changed in 2010 with the passage of the Foreign Account Tax Compliance Act (FATCA) which ushered in a new era of dramatically increased cross-border tax transparency and information sharing of non-U.S. accounts held by U.S. citizens and other U.S. taxable persons. Therefore, continued failure to properly report PFICs on a U.S. tax return exposes U.S. taxpayers to a high risk that the IRS will eventually uncover the lack of disclosure and impose tax, interest, and penalty charges that can potentially consume most of the return on investment.

What are PFICs?

The acronym “Passive Foreign Investment Company” (PFICs) bears a resemblance to exotic and highly specialized investments. As a result, many Americans automatically assume that they do not own any. For many unsuspecting Americans abroad, this conclusion is a mistake. PFICs are simply “pooled investments” registered outside of the United States encompassing mutual funds, exchange-traded funds (EFTs), closed-end funds, hedge funds, insurance products, and non-U.S. pension plans. Money-market funds can also turn a bank account into a PFIC, as these accounts are essentially short-term fixed-income mutual funds. In addition, PFIC rules apply to investments held inside foreign pension funds unless those pension plans are recognized by the U.S. as “qualified” under the terms of a double-taxation treaty between the U.S. and the host country. Due to FATCA, the likelihood that the IRS will eventually identify unreported PFICs has increased dramatically. Finally, PFIC rules apply equally to Americans abroad, as well as Americans living in the U.S., although the problem remains much more common among American taxpayers living abroad.

The tax treatment of PFICs is extremely punitive compared to that of similar investments incorporated in the U.S. For example, an American holder of a U.S. incorporated mutual fund invested in European stocks pays the low long-term capital gains rate of 0 to 20% if the fund is held for more than one year. The same American investor holding a nearly identical fund listed in Singapore, the U.K., or any place outside the U.S., will find their investment subject to the PFIC taxation regime, which counts all income (including capital gains) as ordinary income and automatically taxes it at the top marginal income tax rate of 37%. In some cases, the total tax on a PFIC investment may exceed 50% due to the complex rules regarding the timing of PFIC income recognition. Furthermore, capital losses on PFICs can only offset other investment gains in limited circumstances.

Lastly, it should be stated clearly that PFICs are foreign REGISTERED funds, not funds that invest in foreign investments. For example, a fund registered in Ireland that invests in U.S. stocks is a PFIC, as opposed to a U.S. registered fund that invests in European stocks.

“The tax treatment of PFICS is extremely punitive compared to…similar investments incorporated in the U.S.”

PFIC Compliance for Non-U.S. Mutual Funds

High tax rates are not the only disadvantage of PFICs for American investors. The other major PFIC complication is the onerous task of simply complying with IRS reporting rules for PFICs. Ownership is most common among expatriate Americans, many of whom employ accountants specializing in cross-border tax preparation for Americans abroad. However, hiring an expatriate tax specialist does not guarantee that the proper PFIC related filings are being made, and the taxes paid.

Often, the client inadvertently fails to divulge (and the tax accountant fails to request) the necessary information on the client’s mutual funds, ETFs, hedge funds, or other financial instruments. In other cases, if the client and the tax preparer have negotiated a fixed fee for tax preparation, the preparer may be reluctant to ask about possible PFICs because record keeping and preparation time for the complicated form 8621 is estimated by the IRS to be 22 hours per year!

As a result of the 2010 FATCA, a separate form 8621 must be filed every year for each PFIC. Form 8621 used to only be filed for the years in which the fund paid distributions to the fund holders. It does not take long to realize that filing form 8621 for multiple PFIC investments might quickly run up a tax preparation bill to many thousands of dollars, no matter how much (or little) the underlying investments are worth, and their performance over time.

This scary picture raises an obvious question: If this is such a big trap, why has there not been more discussion of the issue, and why have I never read about it before? The reason is that until now the IRS faced many obstacles to enforcing the PFIC rules and lacked the resources to go after filers on the issue. Failure to file form 8621, and properly report PFICs has hardly ever resulted in an audit or a prosecution for tax fraud. The PFIC issue has been safely ignored until now, even by professional tax preparers. Times have changed since the passage of FATCA.

FATCA makes PFIC Reporting Mandatory

Not only does FATCA require new self-reporting on PFICs, and other foreign-held financial assets, it also requires all “foreign financial institutions” to report the assets held by U.S. citizens, and U.S. permanent residents, directly to the IRS. While it may seem hard to believe that foreign financial institutions would willingly comply with such reporting requirements, the severe sanctions imposed by the IRS on non-compliant financial institutions have led to nearly universal compliance with FATCA induced regulations. All U.S. citizens must assume that the IRS will have a direct, and easily accessible view of their holdings in foreign financial institutions. It will be easy to cross-reference direct reports by these institutions to the IRS with forms 8938 and 8621 as well as determining whether your PFIC investments have been properly reported, and the tax properly calculated and paid.

PFIC Compliant Investments

This issue ultimately serves to demonstrate that it is necessary for all American expatriates to understand that international financial planning complications are magnified by the various tax regimes affecting cross-border or international investors. PFIC rules are just one of many reasons why American investors need to keep their investment funds in U.S. accounts, even if they are investing globally. A thorough analysis of the tax, reporting, cost, and security issues of foreign investments invariably leads to the conclusion that savvy American investors must remain globally invested but do so through U.S. financial institutions to manage the myriad of tax and regulatory issues.

Let’s Talk

Find out how Creative Planning can help you maximize your wealth.

This commentary is provided for general information purposes only and should not be construed as investment, tax or legal advice, and does not constitute an attorney/client relationship. Past performance of any market results is no assurance of future performance. The information contained herein has been obtained from sources deemed reliable but is not guaranteed.

Related Content

“Your wealth works harder when it works together.”

Peter Mallouk

President & CEO, Creative Planning

Serving Clients Nationwide

50

STATES & ABROAD

Providing financial peace of mind across the globe

$225

BILLION

Combined assets under management & advisement as of December 31, 2021

#1 Ranking

RIA Channel®’s List of Top 100 Wealth Managers (2020)*

$225 Billion

Combined assets under management & advisement as of December 31, 2021

Serving Americans abroad and cross-border families in over 50 countries.